Two nursing directors are in a recurring dispute over who controls a shared float pool. Each has escalated complaints to the CNO, and staff morale on both service lines is falling. Which approach by the CNO is most likely to produce a lasting resolution?
Show answer & explanation
Answer: C
Decide the allocation herself and announce it, so the disagreement ends immediately: A forcing approach ends the dispute quickly but does not address underlying interests, so it is likely to come back.
Assign the float pool to the director with more seniority to preserve the reporting structure: Seniority does not address operational needs and can deepen resentment.
Bring both directors together to define shared goals and jointly design the allocation criteria: Correct. A collaborative (problem-solving) approach brings out both parties' interests and builds shared ownership of the solution, which is best for important, recurring conflicts.
Avoid becoming involved and tell both directors to settle the issue between themselves: Avoidance after repeated escalation lets the conflict and its effect on staff continue.
For important, recurring conflicts where both parties' commitment matters, collaboration (win-win problem solving) beats forcing, avoiding or accommodating.