An 86-year-old with stage 5 CKD, advanced heart failure and declining function tells the nurse after a long talk with the family, "I don't want dialysis. I want to stay comfortable at home." The patient has decision-making capacity. What is the nurse's most appropriate response?
Show answer & explanation
Answer: D
Arrange a psychiatric referral, because refusing dialysis suggests depression: Depression should be screened for when it is suspected. But a capable patient's informed choice of conservative care is not, by itself, evidence of depression.
Explain that dialysis is the standard of care and must be started: A capable adult may decline dialysis. Pressuring the patient overrides autonomy, and dialysis may bring little survival or quality-of-life benefit for frail older adults with heavy comorbidity.
Ask the family to persuade the patient to try dialysis for a few months: A time-limited trial is something to offer the patient directly, not to push through the family. That approach undermines the patient's own decision.
Support the choice and coordinate conservative care with the palliative team: Correct. Conservative kidney management is a legitimate, planned option. The nurse supports the patient's informed choice and coordinates symptom management, advance care planning and team support.
For frail older adults with high comorbidity, conservative kidney management with interdisciplinary palliative support is an accepted alternative to dialysis that respects patient autonomy.