On a frozen-meal packaging line, failure mode A (allergen-containing sauce filled into an unlabeled tray) is rated S = 10, O = 3, D = 4. Failure mode B (tray film seal wrinkled) is rated S = 4, O = 5, D = 6. The team has set no RPN action threshold. Which conclusion is most appropriate?
Show answer & explanation
Answer: A
- 1. RPN = S × O × D.
- 2. No table constants are needed; ratings are on 1–10 scales.
- 3. A: 10 × 3 × 4 = 120; B: 4 × 5 × 6 = 120.
- 4. The RPNs are equal (120 each).
- 5. Because A has severity 10 (consumer safety), it is addressed first; the RPN tie does not mean equal risk.
Act on A first, because its severity rating is 10: Correct. Both RPNs are 120 (10 × 3 × 4 and 4 × 5 × 6), but A can harm a consumer with an allergy; severity 9–10 modes get priority regardless of RPN.
Act on B first, because its O and D ratings are higher: Higher O and D do not outweigh a potential safety effect; B's worst effect is a cosmetic or seal-quality issue.
Act on either first, because the two RPNs are equal: Equal products can hide very different risk profiles; RPN is an ordinal ranking aid, not a measure of risk.
Act on neither, because an RPN of 120 is low: No action threshold was set, and fixed RPN cut-offs ignore severity; a severity-10 mode needs review at any RPN.
Always review severity alongside RPN: a high-severity failure mode warrants action even when its RPN equals or falls below that of a minor mode.