Imani is designing two rectangular murals for a community center. The area of Mural 1 is square feet, and the area of Mural 2 is square feet.
Part D. Later, Imani models the ratio of two mural widths with . She simplifies it to and says the two expressions are equal for every value of except . Which explanation is correct?
Show answer & explanation
Answer: D
- 1.
- 2.
- 3. Simplified: , with and
- 4. Check at : original denominator , so the original is undefined while is defined.
She is correct, because is the only value that makes the denominator of equal to 0.: Looks only at the simplified expression. The original denominator is also 0 at , where the original expression is undefined.
She is not correct, because must also be excluded, since it makes the numerator equal to 0.: Excludes a value that makes the numerator 0; a zero numerator gives a value of 0, which is allowed.
She is not correct, because the expression simplifies to , so is excluded.: Cancels the terms instead of common factors, which changes the expression.
She is not correct, because , so also makes the original denominator equal to 0.: Correct. only when and ; at the original expression is undefined, so must be excluded too.
Excluded values come from every factor of the original denominator, including factors that divide out during simplifying.