Each of the following, if true, helps to explain how both populations could have increased EXCEPT:
Biologist: Over the past five years, the population of meadow voles in the Calder Hills has increased steadily. Yet during the same period, the population of red-tailed hawks in the hills, which prey heavily on voles, has also grown considerably. Hawks are among the voles’ principal predators in the region, and in most habitats an increase in hawks is followed by a decline in voles.
Show answer & explanation
Answer: B
An unusually abundant seed supply in recent years has allowed voles in the Calder Hills to breed more often each season.: Explains it: higher vole reproduction can outpace the losses to more hawks.
Red-tailed hawks in the Calder Hills have been observed catching voles more frequently in recent years than they did previously.: Correct. This is the answer because it does not explain anything. More hawk kills of voles makes a rising vole population harder to understand, so it deepens the puzzle.
Foxes, which once killed far more of the Calder Hills’ voles than hawks did, have nearly disappeared from the area.: Explains it: the loss of a bigger vole predator can more than offset additional hawk predation.
The growth of the hawk population has been driven mainly by a rise in rabbits, which the hawks prefer to voles whenever rabbits are available.: Explains it: more hawks need not mean more vole kills if the hawks are mostly eating rabbits.
Dense new ground cover in the hills has made voles much harder for hawks to spot from the air.: Explains it: each hawk catches fewer voles, so the hawk increase need not cut into the vole population.
Explain EXCEPT. Four answers explain how prey and predator both grew. The credited answer is the one that fails to explain, here by making the puzzle worse.