An owner set up a new 200-L freshwater aquarium 10 days ago, added 20 goldfish on the same day, and feeds them twice daily. Over the last 2 days, 6 fish have died, and the others gasp at the surface, have reddened gills, and are lethargic. Water temperature is 75.2°F (24.0°C), and pH is 7.8. No white spots are seen on the fish. The owner's daily water-test readings are shown in the chart. Which of the following is the most likely cause of the fish losses?
Show answer & explanation
Answer: C
Low dissolved oxygen from overheating: The water temperature is normal for goldfish, and the chart shows a toxic ammonia load.
Nitrite toxicity (brown blood disease): Nitrite is rising but still low; it peaks after ammonia as the biofilter matures.
Ammonia toxicity from an uncycled biofilter: Correct. A tank stocked fully on day 1 has no established nitrifying bacteria, so ammonia from fish waste climbs steadily ("new tank syndrome"). At pH 7.8 more of it is in the toxic un-ionized form, damaging gills and causing gasping and deaths. Nitrite is only starting to rise.
Ichthyophthiriasis (white spot disease): Would show white spots on the skin and fins, which are absent.
Low-pH (acid) shock: The pH is 7.8, which makes ammonia more toxic, not less.
New tank, full stocking and rising ammonia: ammonia toxicity from an uncycled biofilter; higher pH makes it worse.