During an oral reading check on a grade-level passage, a fourth grader reads with 98% accuracy at a rate within the expected range for the grade. However, the student reads in a flat voice, ignores commas and question marks, and pauses in the middle of phrases. Which choice correctly identifies the area of need and an appropriate strategy?
Show answer & explanation
Answer: D
Accuracy; teach a step-by-step decoding routine for multisyllabic words: 98% accuracy is a strong independent-level score, so decoding is not the problem.
Rate; use timed one-minute readings to push for more speed: The rate is already in the expected range, and pressing for speed tends to make phrasing and expression worse.
Comprehension; assign more independent silent reading time: Nothing in the data points to a comprehension deficit, and unmonitored silent reading does not target expression or phrasing.
Prosody; model phrased reading, then use repeated readers' theater: Correct. Flat expression, ignored punctuation, and odd phrase breaks are prosody problems; teacher modeling plus purposeful repeated reading (such as readers' theater) builds phrasing and expression.
Fluency has three parts: accuracy, rate, and prosody. Match the strategy to the weak part; for prosody, model phrasing and use repeated, performance-oriented reading.