A 22-year-old soccer player felt a 'pop' in his right knee while pivoting, followed by rapid swelling within 2 hours. He now has a large effusion and a sense that the knee 'gives way.' Which physical examination maneuver is most sensitive for the injury most likely present?
Show answer & explanation
Answer: B
McMurray test with rotation: McMurray tests for meniscal tears (a painful click with flexion-extension and rotation). It does not assess anterior translation of the tibia.
Lachman test: Correct. A pivoting injury with a pop and rapid hemarthrosis suggests an ACL tear. The Lachman test (anterior tibial translation at 20–30° of flexion) is the most sensitive exam maneuver for ACL tears.
Posterior drawer test: The posterior drawer tests the posterior cruciate ligament, which is usually injured by a direct blow to the proximal tibia (for example a dashboard injury).
Valgus stress test at 30°: Valgus stress tests the medial collateral ligament, typically injured by a blow to the lateral knee. MCL injuries are extra-articular and rarely cause a large hemarthrosis.
Pivot, pop and rapid effusion suggest an ACL tear, and the Lachman test is the most sensitive maneuver. The pivot-shift test is the most specific.