This question has two parts. Answer Part One and then answer Part Two.
Part One
How is the way the events are told in Passage 1 different from the way they are told in Passage 2?
Read the following passages about the same winter night. Passage 1 is "Soup by Candlelight" by Bianca Holt. Passage 2 is "The Knock at Number Nine" by Daniel Kwan. Then answer the questions that follow.
Passage 1: Soup by Candlelight
1Everyone on Linden Street knew to stay away from Mr. Alvarez. At least, that's what I thought. He lived alone in the gray house next to ours, and the only time I had ever heard him speak was the summer he yelled at my little brother, Dev, for chasing a ball across his yard.
2So when the ice storm knocked out the power on our whole street, I did not expect to spend the evening at his kitchen table.
3It started around four o'clock. The lights flickered, buzzed, and went dark. The refrigerator stopped humming. By dinnertime, our house was so cold that I could see my breath. Mom lit candles and heated a pot of vegetable soup on our little camping stove.
4Then she looked out the window at the gray house. "There's no light at all over there," she said. "Mr. Alvarez doesn't have a fireplace. Let's bring him some soup."
5"Mom, no," I said. "He doesn't like people." I was sure he would slam the door in our faces.
6But Mom was already filling a thermos. Dev grabbed the flashlight, and the three of us crunched across the frozen yard. My heart was pounding as Mom knocked.
7For a long time, nothing happened. Then the door opened a crack. Mr. Alvarez stood there wrapped in two sweaters and a wool hat. "What do you want?" he said sharply.
8Mom held up the thermos. "Soup," she said. "And company, if you'd like it."
9He looked at the thermos. He looked at us. Then, to my surprise, he opened the door wide.
10His kitchen was even colder than ours. We sat close together around the table while Dev aimed the flashlight at the ceiling so the light spread around the room. Mr. Alvarez ate two bowls of soup without saying a word. Then he pointed at an old photograph on the wall of a woman kneeling in a garden full of red flowers.
11"That's my sister, Lucia," he said. "She planted every tulip in that yard. When she moved to Arizona to be near her grandchildren, I promised to keep them growing just the way she liked." He looked at Dev. "That's why I yelled about the ball. I'm sorry I never explained."
12Dev's mouth fell open. So did mine.
13For the next two hours, Mr. Alvarez told us stories about the street when he was a boy, back when it was a dirt road and every kid on the block went skating on the pond behind it. He even laughed, a rusty laugh that sounded like it hadn't been used in a long time.
14When the power came back on near midnight, all of us cheered. Walking home, I looked back at the gray house. A light was glowing in the kitchen window, and Mr. Alvarez was waving.
15I waved back. I had been wrong about him for a long time.
Passage 2: The Knock at Number Nine
1By six o'clock, Felipe Alvarez had put on his second sweater. The furnace had gone silent when the power failed, and the cold crept in under the doors like water.
2He sat at the kitchen table in the dark and listened to the ice ticking against the windows. He had a flashlight somewhere, but he could not remember where Lucia used to keep it. Lucia had always known where everything was.
3Across the yard, he could see candlelight moving in the Greenes' windows. He thought about walking over. He could ask if they had an extra blanket. But then he remembered the summer he had shouted at their boy for running through the tulips. They probably thought he was a grumpy old man. Maybe he was.
4"I'll be fine," he said out loud to the empty kitchen. The words did not sound very sure.
5At seven o'clock, someone knocked. Felipe's heart jumped. He did not want anyone to see how cold the house had become, or how much he had hoped someone would come. He pulled his hat down low and opened the door just a crack.
6"What do you want?" The words came out sharper than he meant them to.
7Mrs. Greene stood on the step with a thermos. Beside her were her two children, the boy with the flashlight and the girl, who looked like she wanted to run home.
8"Soup," Mrs. Greene said. "And company, if you'd like it."
9Felipe felt something loosen in his chest. He opened the door wide.
10The soup was thick with carrots and beans, and it was the first warm thing he had eaten all day. He was so grateful that he could not think of anything to say, so he simply ate. When he finally looked up, he saw the girl glance at Lucia's photograph on the wall.
11Suddenly he wanted them to know. He told them about Lucia and her tulips, and he apologized to the boy. The children's faces changed from worried to curious. Soon Felipe was telling stories he had not told in years—about sledding down Linden Street when it was still a dirt road, and about the pond where everyone skated in winter.
12When the lights blinked back on, the children cheered. Felipe walked them to the door and stood in his warm, bright kitchen, waving until they reached their own porch.
13After they were gone, he found Lucia's old flashlight in the drawer by the stove, right where it had always been. He set it on the table where he could see it. Tomorrow, he decided, he would bake something and carry it next door himself.
Show answer & explanation
Answer: D
Passage 1 is told by Mr. Alvarez, and Passage 2 is told by the girl who brings him soup.: Reverses the narrators: Passage 1 is told by the girl ("I said"), and Passage 2 is told by an outside narrator.
Passage 1 tells what happens before the storm, and Passage 2 tells what happens after the storm.: Both passages tell about the same night during the storm; they differ in who tells it, not when.
Passage 1 shares the thoughts of every character, and Passage 2 shares only the girl's thoughts.: Reverses the two passages: the girl in Passage 1 can only guess what others think.
Passage 1 shares only the girl's thoughts, and Passage 2 shares what Mr. Alvarez thinks and feels.: Correct. Passage 1 is first person ("I was sure he would slam the door"), so readers know only the girl's thoughts. Passage 2 is third person and tells Mr. Alvarez's private thoughts and feelings.
A first-person narrator ("I") knows only his or her own thoughts; a third-person narrator can tell readers what a character thinks inside.