A citizen group sends a proper 60-day notice of ongoing NPDES permit violations at a plant. Before the 60 days run, the state files a civil action in state court against the plant for the same violations and is diligently prosecuting it. What is the effect on the group?
Show answer & explanation
Answer: C
The group may still sue, because its notice was timely and proper: Proper notice is necessary but not sufficient; diligent government prosecution in court bars the suit.
The group's suit must be merged into a state administrative order: The bar here comes from a court action, and the statute gives no merger into an administrative order.
The group may not sue but may intervene in the court action as of right: Correct. CWA §505(b)(1)(B) bars a citizen suit when EPA or the state has commenced and is diligently prosecuting a civil or criminal action in court for the same violations, but any citizen may intervene in that action as a matter of right.
The group may sue only for civil penalties the state did not seek: There is no carve-out for penalties not sought; the citizen suit is barred while the government diligently prosecutes.
Citizen suits supplement, not replace, government enforcement: diligent prosecution in court bars them, but citizens may intervene.