Ten months ago, the sole owner of Holloway Securities, an introducing firm, contributed $200,000 of new equity capital. Holloway has $400,000 of excess net capital, and the owner wants to withdraw $60,000 of that contribution. Which statement is accurate?
Show answer & explanation
Answer: C
Permitted, since it is under 30% of excess net capital: Staying under the 15c3-1(e) notice thresholds avoids SEC notice, but it does not lift the one-year treatment of contributed equity.
Permitted without approval below 10% of excess net capital: The 10%-in-35-days approval test is FINRA Rule 4110(c)(2), which applies only to carrying or clearing members; it is not a safe harbor for a one-year-old contribution.
Not permitted within one year without written DEA approval: Correct. Under SEA Rule 15c3-1(c)(2)(i)(G)(2), equity withdrawn within one year of contribution is deemed to have been intended to be withdrawn, so it must be treated as a liability (deducted) unless the firm's designated examining authority approves in writing; FINRA Rule 4110(c)(1), which applies to all members, likewise bars the withdrawal within one year without FINRA's written permission. The contribution is ten months old.
Permitted after two business days' notice to the SEC and FINRA: Two business days' prior notice is the 15c3-1(e)(1) mechanism for large withdrawals; it does not lift the one-year restriction.
Contributed equity stays in the firm for one year: SEA 15c3-1(c)(2)(i)(G)(2) deems an earlier withdrawal intended unless the DEA approves in writing (and FINRA 4110(c)(1) requires FINRA's written permission). This is separate from the 15c3-1(e) notice tests.