A first grader writes 'TRANE' for train, 'FLOTE' for float and 'SETE' for seat, but spells ship, bump and flag correctly. Which conclusion and next instructional step are best supported by this sample?
Show answer & explanation
Answer: A
The student is in the within-word-pattern stage and needs instruction in common long-vowel team spellings such as ai, oa and ea.: Correct. Short vowels, blends and digraphs are secure, and the student marks long vowels but uses the wrong pattern ('uses but confuses'), typical of the within-word-pattern stage.
The student is in the emergent stage and needs instruction in letter names and letter formation.: Emergent spellers use scribbles or random letters; this student represents every sound and spells many words correctly.
The student is in the letter-name–alphabetic stage and needs instruction in short-vowel CVC patterns.: Short-vowel words (ship, bump, flag) are already spelled correctly, so short-vowel instruction is not the need.
The student is in the syllables-and-affixes stage and needs instruction in doubling final consonants before adding suffixes such as -ing.: That stage concerns joining syllables and adding affixes; the errors here are in long-vowel patterns within single-syllable words.
Use spelling errors diagnostically: correct short vowels plus misused long-vowel markers signal the within-word-pattern stage, so teach vowel teams through word sorts.